“Oscar” the Opera | The Art Of Darkness

Oscar, the opera in Philadelphia

The last time Oscar Wilde visited Philadelphia it was to promote an opera. That was during his lecture tour of America in 1882 when a required part of his raison d’être was to be the poster-boy for Gilbert & Sullivan’s latest offering Patience—a comic opera whose purpose was to ridicule the adherents of the Aesthetic Movement. Not that it mattered to Oscar Wilde that he was the movement’s leading representative and the person most closely identified with the ridicule. He always knew he would outlive the mob mentality, and it is an ironic measure of the wisdom of Wilde’s indifference that he has now triumphantly returned to Philadelphia as the subject of an opera himself. The question is: if Oscar the man was indifferent to Patience, would he have had any patience for Oscar the opera?

To a large degree the question is moot. There is no evidence that Wilde was a great lover of music, although he did, of course, attend grand theatrical occasions including the opera. For instance, while in America he took the time to meet the highly acclaimed Italian opera singer Adelina Patti who, like Wilde, was a client of the theatrical impresario Richard D’Oyly Carte. The composer Giuseppe Verdi, writing in 1877, described her as perhaps the finest singer who had ever lived. That night Wilde heard her sing “Bel Raggio” from Semiramide by Rossini (see Patti in Cincinnati).

But whatever Wilde thought of music and singing (and it is my belief he would have thought highly of them in Oscar), he would certainly have recognized the opera production as an exercise in Art. This achievement is due entirely to the fertile imagination of the composer and librettists Morrison and Cox, whose creative instinct to artistically distort imagery in Oscar is entirely Wildean.

In his essay, The Decay Of Lying, Wilde said that “no great artist ever sees things as they really are. If he did, he would cease to be an artist…it is style that makes us believe in a thing”. He gave the example of Holbein’s two-dimensional representations that we recall of Tudor nobility in spite of the fact that Henry VIII did not really look like that. Similarly, no one noticed London fogs until they were painted by the Impressionists who had shown us the mysterious loveliness of their effects. A modern version of this theme may be that Andy Warhol’s silkscreen vision of Marilyn Monroe will remain recognizable longer than any photograph. Life imitates art, Wilde said, far more than art imitates life. The idea is perhaps best summed up in a story Wilde told of a man who was asked by a hostess at a party to come to the window to see a glorious sky, only for him to respond that yet another sunset in nature would be nothing more than a very second-rate Turner.

If we translate Wilde’s painterly allusions to the opera stage, we see that the same is true of Oscar. The opera commendably takes the same artistic license in its staging to present things as they are not, or as Wilde called it: to use the imagery of the beautifully untrue which is the proper aim of Art.


Most vivid is the true-life scenario when Wilde was forced into hiding during his trials to occupy the nursery in the home of his friend, Ada Leverson. Morrison and Cox conflate the settings of the courtroom and nursery by reimagining the judge and jury at Wilde’s trials as Oscar’s playthings; the toys come to life in a clever and long overdue satire of those who condemned Wilde to prison and an early death. Posterity will again be best served if life imitates art, and we now think of Wilde’s judge, Mr Justice Wills, only as a listless and ludicrous jack-in-a-box, allowing us to extend the metaphor and gleefully shut the lid on his homophobic pontificating.

In the opera we also have Wilde’s lover and nemesis, Alfred Douglas, whose role in the Wilde story as homme fatale is brilliantly realized as a dancer only: a silent sprite flitting around Wilde as both irritant and muse. He completes the role in the guise of the grim reaper of Wilde’s demise, in which embodiment, the character’s movements recall the skeletal Danse Macabre that Wilde describes on the window blind in his poem The Harlot’s House, where:

the ghostly dancers spin 

To sound of horn and violin, 

Like black leaves wheeling in the wind.

The allusion reminds us that Oscar the opera is a dark piece. This approach is entirely legitimate as many people often begin and end their experience of Wilde with his classic comedies. It is impossible to avoid the lightness in Wilde (and the opera has several amusing moments, all of them capture the essential Wilde), but it is salutary to be reminded that his life was ultimately sad.

If you wish to meet Wilde you will be attracted by the bot mots and aphorisms of his life; but if you wish to know Wilde you must also understand the pain and pathos of his death. This is why the opera depicts Wilde not in the drawing rooms of his comedies but in the courtroom and prison cell of his tragedy. So go to Oscar for the music and singing, but do not overlook that a gay and gentle man is superimposed onto the art of darkness. He was subjected to the prison yard hanging of a fellow inmate; the starving of little boys; the latrine atmosphere of the tiny cell; the cruel regime of privation; the torture of hard labor. From this perspective the idea will resonate how far we have come in rehabilitating Wilde from social pariah to modern thinker and moralist.


Part of that the rehabilitation, pf course, is the triumph of Wilde’s sexual identity. So that in an era of same-sex marriage, Wilde’s own heterosexual marriage is noticeable by its absence from the opera. I suspect this is deliberate, and an artistic decision. It doesn’t trouble me: any chronicler of Wilde’s life should welcome this an artistic stepping stone in the cultural shift. It can be read as another snub to the ignorance of Victorian courts and prisons. It would not have troubled Wilde, either. He was a man possessed of insight into the relation of art and life. Indeed, apropos The Decay Of Lying, he posited that art was not a mirror to life, it was a veil through which we see it. But it is also true of Wilde that personality was a veil to lifestyle. So it is ironic, and fittingly inverted, that when the English judicial system denied Wilde that veil, it revealed a personality that was to become a mirror in which the law would one day see reflected its own face of prejudice.

© John Cooper, 2015.

Images courtesy Opera Philadelphia

3 thoughts on ““Oscar” the Opera | The Art Of Darkness

  1. Dear John,

    I used to agree with you that Oscar knew little about music, but about 10 years ago I was at the Center for 18th Century Studies and Oscar Wilde and his Circle in L.A. Merlin Holland came to deliver a talk on the subject and held about 25 of us rapt for an hour while he spoke about Wilde’s knowledge of music. Much substance, nothing throwaway.

    Best, Linda Zatli

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Linda,

    Thank you for your informed contribution about Wilde’s knowledge of music. But isn’t there is a distinction between a ‘knowledge’ of music, and, as I was suggesting, there being little evidence that Wilde was a great ‘lover’ of it. At least I hope we can maintain a distinction, because if so, we will have done something wonderfully Wildean and differed to agree!

    That’s because I, too, think it probable that Wilde had a working knowledge of music. He often placed musical settings and allusions in his works, and I recall a piece on Oscholars [1] citing examples probably similar to the talk that you heard. I was also pleasantly surprised recently (when working with Opera Philadelphia on songs based on Wilde’s poems) to note how much musicality there is in his early poetry—indeed, that some of it was written specifically as lyric.

    However, I wouldn’t presume to be an authority on Wilde’s love or knowledge of music. What I really meant was the apparent lack of it in his personal life: it occurred to me that we don’t often hear Wilde waxing poetic about music, or musicians, in the same way he does about literature, art and life.




Leave a Reply to Linda Zatlin Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s